Investment

5

min read

Index funds vs. stocks

Amanda Gile

Amanda Gile

October 22, 2025

When it comes to long-term financial planning, where you invest your hard-earned money often determines whether you build wealth and secure a healthy retirement or fail to meet your financial goals. 

Two popular approaches to investing — index funds and individual stocks — offer unique benefits and challenges. One can offer broad exposure and low maintenance. The other can bring higher risk and may require active oversight. Understanding their differences is key to finding the approach that fits your risk tolerance and time commitment. 

Read on to learn about index funds versus stocks. We’ll show you how they work and what to watch out for. We’ll also explore how annuity products can complement your investment strategy for stable, tax-advantaged growth.

{{key-takeaways}}

What is index investing, and how does an index work?

Index investing can be a passive investment strategy that seeks to replicate the performance of a specific market index, such as the S&P 500 or the Nasdaq. Fund managers typically structure these as an exchange-traded fund (ETF) or mutual fund. Rather than attempting to outperform the stock market through active stock selection, they can offer long-term growth with minimal intervention. 

A market index benchmarks a specific segment of the market. For example, the S&P 500 tracks the performance of 500 large U.S. companies. Investing in an S&P 500 index fund can give you exposure to those companies, proportionate to their weighting. 

When comparing stocks vs. ETFs and mutual funds, you’ll see simplicity and low costs are major selling points for these index funds. They can also require minimal investor management since they automatically adjust and rebalance, making them ideal for investors seeking a low-maintenance portfolio. By spreading investments across many companies, index funds can reduce the risk associated with individual company performance.

For investors seeking stable, tax-advantaged growth to balance their index fund investing, Gainbridge’s simplified annuity products, such as fixed indexed annuities, can add value and diversification to your portfolio. Some offer predictable interest and tax deferral, which can provide a reliable income stream for retirement planning

What are individual stocks, and how do they work?

While index funds can offer broad market exposure, an individual stock represents ownership in one company. 

Buying individual stocks can be an active investing approach that requires ongoing attention and informed decision making. Investors typically have to stay engaged — researching companies, tracking market shifts, and navigating changing conditions. 

Your potential returns from investing in stocks typically come from two primary sources: 

  • Share appreciation: This is where the stock's price increases over time due to factors such as company's growth and market demand.
  • Dividends: Companies may regularly pay shareholders dividends from profits.

Individual stocks can carry higher risk than index funds because you tie your investment to one company, demanding greater risk tolerance and constant monitoring. The primary disadvantage of single-stock investing is the reliance on one stock to perform well. There are many factors outside of company performance and growth that can have an impact on the stock price. 

Index funds vs. stocks: Key differences to consider

In addition to weighing the pros and cons of ETFs, mutual funds, and stocks, it’s important to look more closely at the key factors that set them apart. 

Risk level

Before investing, consider how much uncertainty you can handle.

  • Index funds: ETFs and mutual funds may carry lower risk due to diversification across many companies. A single company’s failure can have less impact on the overall fund.
  • Stocks: There’s a higher level of risk when investing in individual stocks. Your investment depends on one single company’s stock performance. Market volatility or company-specific issues among other factors can result in substantial losses.

Potential returns

This will vary widely based on investment selection and market conditions. 

  • Index funds: In the long term, these can offer steady, market-average and correlated returns but rarely outperform the market as they are intended to match the performance of a specific market index..
  • Stocks: There’s the potential for higher returns if you pick outperforming companies, but losses can also be substantial.

Diversification

Spreading your money out can help manage risk.

  • Index funds: Mutual funds and ETFs can provide instant diversification and aid in risk management by holding hundreds or thousands of securities across industries and asset classes. Overall diversification will depend on the underlying fund. 
  • Stocks: There’s no diversification here unless you manually build a portfolio of multiple stocks, which may require more capital and effort. Your portfolio is more vulnerable to company-specific events. 

Time commitment

Each approach comes with a different level of involvement.

  • Index funds: These have a passive “set it and forget it” approach with minimal time requirements as the fund tracks the index automatically. It still is important to monitor your investments to make sure they are aligned with your plan and goals. 
  • Stocks: There can be a substantial time commitment, requiring ongoing research, monitoring, and decision-making to stay informed about market and company developments.

Costs and fees

Expenses can impact your long-term returns. 

  • Index funds: These generally have lower fees, especially ETFs, which can carry expense ratios as low as 0.03%. Trading costs are minimal because automated systems rebalance the portfolio.
  • Stocks: Many brokerages now offer commission-free trading, but investing in individual stocks can often involve more frequent trading. This can lead to higher costs — such as for research tools or higher capital gains taxes from constant buying and selling — to support active trading.

Whether you invest in index funds or individual stocks, Gainbridge annuities offer a way to balance growth potential with risk management. This stability can benefit low-risk investors who want to protect their long-term retirement goals from market swings. 

{{inline-cta}}

Pros and cons of index funds vs. individual stocks

Both investment types come with their own set of advantages and disadvantages.

Pros and cons of index funds

Index funds are a popular choice for long-term, low-maintenance portfolios. 

Pros:

  • Diversification
  • Low costs
  • Can offer simplicity in comparison to selecting individual stocks
  • Consistent returns with the underlying index
  • Tax efficiency opportunities 

Cons:

  • Lack of control over selecting stocks
  • Market risk during broad market downturns

Pros and cons of investing in individual stocks

There’s the potential for more upside when investing in individual stocks, but it can also require greater effort and carry higher risks.

Pros:

  • Potential for higher returns
  • Greater control 
  • Portfolio fine-tuned flexibility

Cons:

  • Generally, higher risk
  • Can requires a greater time commitment
  • Lack of instant diversification
  • Potential for higher emotional stress

Which is better for you?

Deciding to invest in index funds or individual stocks depends on factors like your financial goals, risk tolerance, and time availability. 

Index funds are typically better for hands-off, diversified investing. They may appeal to people who prefer a more straightforward, lower-maintenance approach that can offer steady, long-term growth potential mirroring the underlying index. 

If your goal is to beat the market, and you’re comfortable with a higher level of risk, you may look to buy individual stocks. This path typically requires a higher time commitment, but selecting the right investment, although risky, can lead to significant portfolio gains. 

For those looking to balance market gains with steady income, Gainbridge’s annuity calculator can help you explore how a fixed indexed annuity may fit in your overall investment strategy. By combining index funds or stocks with Gainbridge’s products, you can create a diversified approach tailored to your retirement needs.

Complement your investments with an annuity from Gainbridge

Both index funds and individual stocks can offer distinct pathways to wealth creation, each with its own set of advantages and disadvantages. Regardless of which option you choose, Gainbridge’s digital-first annuities can complement your investment strategy by providing tax-advantaged growth and guaranteed income — with no hidden fees or commissions. Explore how Gainbridge can help you build a balanced, retirement-focused portfolio.

This article is intended for informational purposes only. It is not intended to provide, and should not be interpreted as, individualized investment, legal, or tax advice. For advice concerning your own situation please contact the appropriate professional.  The GainbridgeⓇ digital platform provides informational and educational resources intended only for self-directed purposes. Guarantees are backed by the financial strength and claims-paying ability of the issuer.

Diversification does not assure a profit or protect against a loss in declining markets. All investing involves risk, including the possible loss of principal. Past performance is not indicative of future results. It is not possible to invest directly in an index. Exposure to an asset class represented by an index may be available through investable instruments based on that index.

Related Topics
Want more from your savings?
Compare your options
Question 1/8
How old are you?
Why we ask
Some products have age-based benefits or rules. Knowing your age helps us point you in the right direction.
Question 2/8
Which of these best describes you right now?
Why we ask
Life stages influence how you think about saving, growing, and using your money.
Question 3/8
What’s your main financial goal?
Why we ask
Different annuities are designed to support different goals. Knowing yours helps us narrow the options.
Question 4/8
What are you saving this money for?
Why we ask
Knowing your “why” helps us understand the role these funds play in your bigger financial picture.
Question 5/8
What matters most to you in an annuity?
Why we ask
This helps us understand the feature you value most.
Question 6/8
When would you want that income to begin?
Why we ask
Some annuities allow income to start right away, while others allow it later. This timing helps guide the right match.
Question 6/8
How long are you comfortable investing your money for?
Why we ask
Some annuities are built for shorter terms, while others reward you more over time.
Question 7/8
How much risk are you comfortable taking?
Why we ask
Some annuities offer stable, predictable growth while others allow for more market-linked potential. Your comfort level matters.
Question 8/8
How would you prefer to handle taxes on your earnings?
Why we ask
Some annuities defer taxes until you withdraw, while others require you to pay taxes annually on interest earned. This choice helps determine the right structure.

Based on your answers, a non–tax-deferred MYGA could be a strong fit

This type of annuity offers guaranteed growth and flexible access. Because it’s not tax-deferred, you can withdraw your money before age 59½ without IRS penalties. Plus, many allow you to take out up to 10% of your account value each year penalty-free — making it a versatile option for guaranteed growth at any age.

Fixed interest rate for a set term

Penalty-free 10% withdrawal per year

Avoid a surprise tax bill at the end of your term

Withdraw before 59½ with no IRS penalty

Earn

${CD_DIFFERENCE}

the national CD average

${CD_RATE}

APY

Our rates up to

${RATE_FB_UPTO}

Based on your answers, a non–tax-deferred MYGA could be a strong fit for your retirement

A non–tax-deferred MYGA offers guaranteed fixed growth with predictable returns — without stock market risk. Because interest is paid annually and taxed in the year it’s earned, it can be a useful way to grow retirement savings without facing a large lump-sum tax bill at the end of your term.

Fixed interest rate for a set term

Penalty-free 10% withdrawal per year

Avoid a surprise tax bill at the end of your term

Withdraw before 59½ with no IRS penalty

Earn

${CD_DIFFERENCE}

the national CD average

${CD_RATE}

APY

Our rates up to

${RATE_FB_UPTO}

Based on your answers, a tax-deferred MYGA could be a strong fit

A tax-deferred MYGA offers guaranteed fixed growth for a set term, with no risk to your principal. Because taxes on interest are deferred until you withdraw funds, more of your money stays invested and working for you — making it a strong option for growing retirement savings over time.

Fixed interest rate for a set term

Tax-deferred earnings help savings grow faster

Zero risk to your principal

Flexible term lengths to fit your timeline

Guaranteed rates up to

${RATE_SP_UPTO} APY

Based on your answers, a tax-deferred MYGA with a Guaranteed Lifetime Withdrawal Benefit could be a strong fit

This type of annuity combines the predictable growth of a tax-deferred MYGA with the security of guaranteed lifetime withdrawals. You’ll earn a fixed interest rate for a set term, and when you’re ready, you can turn your savings into a dependable income stream for life — no matter how long you live or how the markets perform.

Steady income stream for life

Tax-deferred fixed-rate growth

Up to ${RATE_PF_UPTO} APY, guaranteed

Keeps paying even if your account balance reaches $0

Protection from market ups and downs

Based on your answers, a fixed index annuity tied to the S&P 500® could be a strong fit

This type of annuity protects your principal while giving you the potential for growth based on the performance of the S&P 500® Total Return Index, up to a set cap. You’ll benefit from market-linked growth without risking your original investment, along with tax-deferred earnings for the length of the term.

100% principal protection

Growth linked to the S&P 500® Total Return Index (up to a cap)

Tax-deferred earnings over the term

Guaranteed minimum return regardless of market performance

Let's talk through your options

It seems you’re not sure where to begin — and that’s okay. Our team can help you understand how different annuities work, answer your questions, and give you the information you need to feel confident about your next step.

Our team is available Monday through Friday, 8:00 AM–5:00 PM ET.

Phone

Call us at
1-866-252-9439

Email

Let’s find something that works for you

Your answers don’t match any of our current quiz results, but you can still explore other types of annuities that are available. Take a look to see if one of these could fit your needs:

Non–Tax-Deferred MYGA

Guaranteed fixed growth with flexible access

May be ideal for:

those who want to purchase an annuity and withdraw their funds before 591/2.

Learn more
Tax-Deferred MYGA

Fixed-rate growth with tax-deferred earnings for long-term savers

May be ideal for:

those seeking fixed growth for retirement savings.

Learn more
Tax-Deferred MYGA with GLWB

Guaranteed growth plus a lifetime income stream

May be ideal for:

those seeking lifetime income.

Learn more
Fixed Index Annuity tied to the S&P 500®

Market-linked growth with principal protection

May be ideal for:

those looking to get index-linked growth for their retirement money, without risking their principal.

Learn more

Consider a flexible fit for your age and goals

You mentioned you’re looking for [retirement savings / income for life / stock market growth], but since you’re under 25, you might benefit more from a product that gives you more flexibility to access your money early.

A non–tax-deferred MYGA offers guaranteed fixed growth and allows you to withdraw funds before age 59½ without the 10% IRS penalty. You can also take out up to 10% of your account value each year without a withdrawal charge, giving you more flexibility while still earning a predictable return.

Highlights:

Fixed interest rate for a set term (3–10 years)

Withdraw before 59½ with no IRS penalty

10% penalty-free withdrawals each year

Interest paid annually and taxable in the year earned

Learn more about non–tax-deferred MYGAs
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Take the Quiz

Stay Ahead. Get the Latest from Gainbridge.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Table of Contents

Share

This is some text inside of a div block.
Amanda Gile

Amanda Gile

Amanda is a licensed insurance agent and digital support associate at Gainbridge®.

Maximize your financial potential

with Gainbridge

Start saving with Gainbridge’s innovative, fee-free platform. Skip the middleman and access annuities directly from the insurance carrier. With our competitive APY rates and tax-deferred accounts, you’ll grow your money faster than ever.

Learn how annuities can contribute to your savings.

Get started

Individual licensed agents associated with Gainbridge® are available to provide customer assistance related to the application process and provide factual information on the annuity contracts, but in keeping with the self-directed nature of the Gainbridge® Digital Platform, the Gainbridge® agents will not provide insurance or investment advice

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Key takeaways
Index funds offer diversification, low costs, and simplicity, making them suitable for long-term investors seeking steady, market-matching growth.
Individual stocks provide higher return potential but require more time, research, and risk tolerance.
Index funds carry lower risk due to diversification, while individual stocks are more volatile and company-dependent.
Curious to see how much your money can grow?

Explore different terms and rates

Use the calculator
Want more from your savings?
Compare your options

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

See how your money can grow with Gainbridge

Try our growth calculator to see your fixed return before you invest.

Interested in annuities? Take your savings knowledge with you

Get a quick breakdown of how Gainbridge® fixed annuities compare — and which one might be right for you.

Index funds vs. stocks

by
Amanda Gile
,
Series 6 and 63 insurance license

When it comes to long-term financial planning, where you invest your hard-earned money often determines whether you build wealth and secure a healthy retirement or fail to meet your financial goals. 

Two popular approaches to investing — index funds and individual stocks — offer unique benefits and challenges. One can offer broad exposure and low maintenance. The other can bring higher risk and may require active oversight. Understanding their differences is key to finding the approach that fits your risk tolerance and time commitment. 

Read on to learn about index funds versus stocks. We’ll show you how they work and what to watch out for. We’ll also explore how annuity products can complement your investment strategy for stable, tax-advantaged growth.

{{key-takeaways}}

What is index investing, and how does an index work?

Index investing can be a passive investment strategy that seeks to replicate the performance of a specific market index, such as the S&P 500 or the Nasdaq. Fund managers typically structure these as an exchange-traded fund (ETF) or mutual fund. Rather than attempting to outperform the stock market through active stock selection, they can offer long-term growth with minimal intervention. 

A market index benchmarks a specific segment of the market. For example, the S&P 500 tracks the performance of 500 large U.S. companies. Investing in an S&P 500 index fund can give you exposure to those companies, proportionate to their weighting. 

When comparing stocks vs. ETFs and mutual funds, you’ll see simplicity and low costs are major selling points for these index funds. They can also require minimal investor management since they automatically adjust and rebalance, making them ideal for investors seeking a low-maintenance portfolio. By spreading investments across many companies, index funds can reduce the risk associated with individual company performance.

For investors seeking stable, tax-advantaged growth to balance their index fund investing, Gainbridge’s simplified annuity products, such as fixed indexed annuities, can add value and diversification to your portfolio. Some offer predictable interest and tax deferral, which can provide a reliable income stream for retirement planning

What are individual stocks, and how do they work?

While index funds can offer broad market exposure, an individual stock represents ownership in one company. 

Buying individual stocks can be an active investing approach that requires ongoing attention and informed decision making. Investors typically have to stay engaged — researching companies, tracking market shifts, and navigating changing conditions. 

Your potential returns from investing in stocks typically come from two primary sources: 

  • Share appreciation: This is where the stock's price increases over time due to factors such as company's growth and market demand.
  • Dividends: Companies may regularly pay shareholders dividends from profits.

Individual stocks can carry higher risk than index funds because you tie your investment to one company, demanding greater risk tolerance and constant monitoring. The primary disadvantage of single-stock investing is the reliance on one stock to perform well. There are many factors outside of company performance and growth that can have an impact on the stock price. 

Index funds vs. stocks: Key differences to consider

In addition to weighing the pros and cons of ETFs, mutual funds, and stocks, it’s important to look more closely at the key factors that set them apart. 

Risk level

Before investing, consider how much uncertainty you can handle.

  • Index funds: ETFs and mutual funds may carry lower risk due to diversification across many companies. A single company’s failure can have less impact on the overall fund.
  • Stocks: There’s a higher level of risk when investing in individual stocks. Your investment depends on one single company’s stock performance. Market volatility or company-specific issues among other factors can result in substantial losses.

Potential returns

This will vary widely based on investment selection and market conditions. 

  • Index funds: In the long term, these can offer steady, market-average and correlated returns but rarely outperform the market as they are intended to match the performance of a specific market index..
  • Stocks: There’s the potential for higher returns if you pick outperforming companies, but losses can also be substantial.

Diversification

Spreading your money out can help manage risk.

  • Index funds: Mutual funds and ETFs can provide instant diversification and aid in risk management by holding hundreds or thousands of securities across industries and asset classes. Overall diversification will depend on the underlying fund. 
  • Stocks: There’s no diversification here unless you manually build a portfolio of multiple stocks, which may require more capital and effort. Your portfolio is more vulnerable to company-specific events. 

Time commitment

Each approach comes with a different level of involvement.

  • Index funds: These have a passive “set it and forget it” approach with minimal time requirements as the fund tracks the index automatically. It still is important to monitor your investments to make sure they are aligned with your plan and goals. 
  • Stocks: There can be a substantial time commitment, requiring ongoing research, monitoring, and decision-making to stay informed about market and company developments.

Costs and fees

Expenses can impact your long-term returns. 

  • Index funds: These generally have lower fees, especially ETFs, which can carry expense ratios as low as 0.03%. Trading costs are minimal because automated systems rebalance the portfolio.
  • Stocks: Many brokerages now offer commission-free trading, but investing in individual stocks can often involve more frequent trading. This can lead to higher costs — such as for research tools or higher capital gains taxes from constant buying and selling — to support active trading.

Whether you invest in index funds or individual stocks, Gainbridge annuities offer a way to balance growth potential with risk management. This stability can benefit low-risk investors who want to protect their long-term retirement goals from market swings. 

{{inline-cta}}

Pros and cons of index funds vs. individual stocks

Both investment types come with their own set of advantages and disadvantages.

Pros and cons of index funds

Index funds are a popular choice for long-term, low-maintenance portfolios. 

Pros:

  • Diversification
  • Low costs
  • Can offer simplicity in comparison to selecting individual stocks
  • Consistent returns with the underlying index
  • Tax efficiency opportunities 

Cons:

  • Lack of control over selecting stocks
  • Market risk during broad market downturns

Pros and cons of investing in individual stocks

There’s the potential for more upside when investing in individual stocks, but it can also require greater effort and carry higher risks.

Pros:

  • Potential for higher returns
  • Greater control 
  • Portfolio fine-tuned flexibility

Cons:

  • Generally, higher risk
  • Can requires a greater time commitment
  • Lack of instant diversification
  • Potential for higher emotional stress

Which is better for you?

Deciding to invest in index funds or individual stocks depends on factors like your financial goals, risk tolerance, and time availability. 

Index funds are typically better for hands-off, diversified investing. They may appeal to people who prefer a more straightforward, lower-maintenance approach that can offer steady, long-term growth potential mirroring the underlying index. 

If your goal is to beat the market, and you’re comfortable with a higher level of risk, you may look to buy individual stocks. This path typically requires a higher time commitment, but selecting the right investment, although risky, can lead to significant portfolio gains. 

For those looking to balance market gains with steady income, Gainbridge’s annuity calculator can help you explore how a fixed indexed annuity may fit in your overall investment strategy. By combining index funds or stocks with Gainbridge’s products, you can create a diversified approach tailored to your retirement needs.

Complement your investments with an annuity from Gainbridge

Both index funds and individual stocks can offer distinct pathways to wealth creation, each with its own set of advantages and disadvantages. Regardless of which option you choose, Gainbridge’s digital-first annuities can complement your investment strategy by providing tax-advantaged growth and guaranteed income — with no hidden fees or commissions. Explore how Gainbridge can help you build a balanced, retirement-focused portfolio.

This article is intended for informational purposes only. It is not intended to provide, and should not be interpreted as, individualized investment, legal, or tax advice. For advice concerning your own situation please contact the appropriate professional.  The GainbridgeⓇ digital platform provides informational and educational resources intended only for self-directed purposes. Guarantees are backed by the financial strength and claims-paying ability of the issuer.

Diversification does not assure a profit or protect against a loss in declining markets. All investing involves risk, including the possible loss of principal. Past performance is not indicative of future results. It is not possible to invest directly in an index. Exposure to an asset class represented by an index may be available through investable instruments based on that index.

Maximize your financial potential with Gainbridge

Start saving with Gainbridge’s innovative, fee-free platform. Skip the middleman and access annuities directly from the insurance carrier. With our competitive APY rates and tax-deferred accounts, you’ll grow your money faster than ever. Learn how annuities can contribute to your savings.

Amanda Gile

Linkin "in" logo

Amanda is a licensed insurance agent and digital support associate at Gainbridge®.