Investing in stocks and mutual funds is often uncertain, but these strategies offer higher returns for those who are willing to face the volatility.  To enjoy direct exposure to high-growth opportunities without the risk of loss, you can get a fixed index annuity (FIA). Read on to discover what an indexed annuity is and if it suits your goals. 

‍

What is a fixed index annuity (FIA)?

Like other annuities, FIAs is a contract between you and an insurance company. A fixed indexed annuity is a tax-deferred, long-term savings option that provides protection for your original deposit when the market goes down, combined with an opportunity for growth. The key feature separating FIAs from other annuities is that they provide you an added opportunity to earn indexed interest based on changes in an external index while offering principal protection opportunity.

For index-based annuity funds, you earn an interest rate linked to a stock market index. One of the most common indexes used in FIAs is the S&P 500, which tracks the average price of the 500 largest companies in the U.S.  When an FIA mirrors the S&P 500, you have the potential to earn interest credits relative to this index’s performance. On the other hand, If the index has a negative year, there is no index interest credit added, but your FIA  does not lose value.

‍

How to fund your fixed index annuity?

Opening an indexed account is fairly simple. First, you can send a lump sum deposit to the insurance company, or make a series of deposits(contributions) until you reach the total amount you wish to invest. 

The years you deposit funds into your FIA are known as the accumulation phase, and you'll usually face penalties like surrender charges or a market value adjustment if you withdraw before this term ends. After the accumulation phase, your annuity transitions to regular withdrawals in the distribution phase. Your FIA's value depends on the pre-agreed terms and the index's performance over the years of accumulation.  Keep in mind: Insurance companies charge fees for issuing FIAs, including costs for administration, , and add-on protections like riders. 

‍

Factors that affect your FIA payouts

The range between an FIA's downside coverage and upper limit shows your projected gains each year, but these numbers don't tell the whole story — the following factors can affect your payouts. 

Loss floors 

A loss floor guarantees you won't lose your principal even when the corresponding index plummets. No matter how low an underlying asset drops, the loss floor creates a threshold your annuity's value can't fall below, dramatically reducing your risk profile. For instance, FIAs typically have a 0% loss floor, the worst-case scenario is that your account's value stays flat. 

Minimum returns 

Minimum returns are like loss floors, but they promise a positive percentage rate regardless of the index's performance. For instance, if an FIA has a minimum yearly return of 2%, the base case is that your account value is credited 2% each year, even if the index falls short of 2%. These guaranteed interest rates ensure you always gain money. 

Return caps 

The tradeoff for guaranteeing against losses is that sometimes the insurance company limits the credit you can earn. Often, FIA contracts may come with stipulations called return caps or max caps, both of which limit your interest earnings — regardless of how high an index rises. For instance, a return cap of 6% on the S&P 500 means you only get to realize 6% gains, even if the S&P 500 shoots above 6%. 

Participation rates 

Besides limiting maximum gains, insurance companies may include participation rates to define how much of an underlying index’s gain can be credited to your account value. For instance, if you have a 70% participation rate and your FIA's index goes up by 5%, you're eligible for 70% of the 5% gain (or 3.5% interest is credited to your account value). 

Insurance providers consider several factors when determining your participation rate, like market conditions, index volatility, and contract duration. They also review participation rates periodically, adjusting as conditions change.

Adjusted value 

When it's time for an insurance company to calculate the gain in an annuitant's account, they combine the fees, participation rates, and max caps, deduct them from the index's performance, and arrive at their adjusted value. Annuity providers credit whatever gains determined by the adjusted value to the investor’s account value and wait for the next term to calculate the next rate. 

Margin fees

Rather than imposing a max cap, some FIAs take out a percentage of the gains each year with margin fees. These extra costs restrict the upper limits a contract holder can be credited without creating a static cutoff. For example, if your FIA has a 2% margin fee and the index gains 8%, you'll only receive 6% interest credit. Although this fee structure creates the opportunity for a higher upside, it can also dampen your earned interest.

{{inline-cta}}

Pros and cons of fixed index annuities

The combination of limited risk and long-term growth makes FIAs attractive, but this strategy isn’t perfect.

Pros of fixed index annuities

• Potential growth and inflation protection: Indexes like the Dow Jones and S&P 500 have solid track records for outpacing inflation rates and offering long-term growth. Although past performance doesn't promise future results, investors might supercharge their savings.
• Downside protection: Don't fear losing your funds in a stock market meltdown. With principal protection, fixed index annuities clear the risk of negative years. 
• Potential for guaranteed retirement income: Some FIAs go beyond principal protection and offer a positive APY on your holdings, so you're always in growth mode.

Cons of fixed index annuities 

• Limited upside: With FIAs, you may miss out on higher gains due if the contract has stipulations like a max cap and margin fees.
• Limited liquidity: While FIA accounts give the underlying index years to grow (a plus), you generally must leave your money untouched for the term of the contract.

‍

Fixed index annuities versus fixed annuities: Which is best? 

Although popular indexes like the S&P 500 have a history of long-term growth, there's no way to guarantee you'll make more with a fixed index annuity versus a traditional fixed annuity. 

The only certainty when comparing these annuity types is the quoted interest rate in a fixed annuity. If you favor predictability, you’ll likely prefer a fixed annuity's rate. And if you’re more interested in growth — and less averse to uncertainty — look into fixed index annuities.